Skip to main content
← Work
UX Research2025

Food Insecurity Discovery Research

Screener DesignSemi-Structured InterviewsAffinity MappingQuestionnaire DesignJTBD AnalysisPersona DevelopmentMixed Methods

Slides from the Desk Research

The project began with desk research. These slides are from that report, which came before the screener, interviews, affinity mapping, and questionnaire.

Key findings slide from a food insecurity secondary research report
Key findingsThe desk research covered global, national, and local figures.
Global scale2.6 billion people

The report cites World Bank and FAO data showing that roughly one third of the global population could not afford a healthy diet.

U.S. trendRising need

Food insecurity rose after pandemic-era supports expired and food prices stayed high.

Local frame1 in 6 locally

The regional estimate for the Mahoning Valley: about 90,000 people struggling with hunger and food insecurity.

Sources: World Bank, FAO, USDA, and regional data, cited in the original report (PDF).

Report slide about healthy food cost as a barrier in food insecurity research
Cost barrierThe report connected healthy food cost to the practical difficulty of sustaining a healthy diet.
Report slide explaining food deserts and food swamps as food access patterns
Food swampsThe research added food swamps to the food-desert picture: places where healthier options exist but are outnumbered by cheaper, less nutritious ones.
Report slide with Mahoning Valley food insecurity recommendations
Local recommendationsThe Mahoning Valley section recommended subsidized community gardens, mobile market and delivery initiatives, and year-round farmers markets.

The Problem

The Mahoning Valley is the post-industrial corridor straddling northeast Ohio and western Pennsylvania, anchored by Youngstown. The economic disruption that began in the late 1970s is still visible in vacancy rates, health outcomes, and food access. Roughly one in six residents, approximately 90,000 people, struggles with food insecurity.

That number says nothing about how people manage it: the decisions they make, the systems they rely on, and the workarounds they have developed. That was what I set out to learn.

The Research Question

The guiding question was broad:

“How can we develop novel, sustainable solutions to improve food security and quality of life for the 90,000 residents (1 in 6 people) in the Mahoning Valley who struggle with food insecurity?”

Research Design

The screener had to identify people with direct experience of food insecurity in the Mahoning Valley without wording that would make them disengage or self-censor. Food insecurity carries stigma.

Privacy: recruitment records, screening responses, and interview transcripts are not published. Examples on this page are paraphrased.

Inclusion Criteria

Three criteria determined eligibility. First, age: participants had to be 18 or older, which avoided the added requirements of research with minors. Second, geography: participants had to live within Mahoning Valley zip codes, since this was a regional study and location shaped food access. Third, active food acquisition: participants had to shop for or otherwise obtain food themselves. The screener verified all three through simple, non-leading questions.

Exclusion Criteria

Professional background mattered. People working in food retail, public health, social services, market research, or food assistance programs were excluded to avoid conflating professional knowledge with lived experience. Participants who had been in a food or nutrition study within the past year were also excluded to guard against research fatigue. Internet access was a practical requirement, since later phases of the study (the questionnaire, potential prototype testing) would happen online.

Language and Framing

The screener introduced the study as research into “food shopping habits in the Mahoning Valley” rather than “food insecurity.” Describing the topic neutrally reduced the chance that participants would feel pre-labeled or defensive before any conversation took place. The closing question asked participants to briefly describe their last grocery shopping experience, a concrete, low-stakes prompt that gave an early signal about how someone talks about food access without requiring them to self-identify as food-insecure.

Two-Population Consideration

I considered recruiting two subpopulations: individuals experiencing food insecurity directly, and social workers or case managers who encounter it professionally. The logic was that frontline professionals could provide a systemic view that individual participants might not have. I scoped the dual-population approach down to keep the study manageable, though I did interview one family services administrator.

Methods

This was a mixed-methods study. The qualitative phase informed the survey instrument, which then tested whether patterns from the interviews held at broader scale.

Discovery Interview Protocol

The discussion guide used semi-structured, open-ended prompts designed to surface behavior instead of opinion. It asked about a specific week, a specific decision, or a specific trip to a food bank or grocery store.

The guide moved through five areas: daily food acquisition routines, decision-making under constraint, use of and friction with existing support systems (SNAP, food banks, community pantries), social and emotional dimensions of food insecurity, and aspirations: what a meaningfully different situation would look like from where they stood.

One early participant was an administrator at a family services agency (not the Ohio Department of Job and Family Services, but a family-based organization). Her agency provided food vouchers to clients in acute need, but she had limited knowledge of the broader food assistance network in the region.

Affinity Diagram

Synthesis happened through a large-scale affinity diagram built from interview transcripts. I pulled discrete observations and quotes onto individual nodes, then clustered them bottom-up by similarity instead of imposing categories in advance.

Some participants had adapted to chronic food insecurity in resourceful ways; others were in acute crisis.

Questionnaire Design

I developed the survey instrument after the qualitative phase. Constructs from the interview synthesis became survey items.

The questionnaire used five questions, each chosen for a specific analytical purpose. A frequency measure asked how many meals were skipped or reduced in the past seven days, producing a concrete behavioral baseline rather than a self-assessment of how food-insecure someone felt. A resource usage question (select all that apply) covered food banks, SNAP, WIC, free meal programs, church organizations, food vouchers, mobile food markets, and community gardens. This generated data on which services were actually used and how many services an individual relied on simultaneously.

A transportation question anchored to the participant's most recent grocery or food resource trip captured real behavior rather than generalized habits. The interview data had surfaced transportation as a significant barrier, and this question provided quantitative data on whether that pattern held at scale. A Likert-scale ranking question forced prioritization across five barriers: money, transportation cost, distance to resources, time constraints, and awareness of available programs. Forcing a rank order instead of independent ratings showed relative importance.

The final question was open-ended, a catch-all for information the structured items might miss. It also tested whether the structured questions were asking about the right things: if open-ended responses consistently raised themes the closed questions had not captured, the instrument would need revision.

Persona Development

The synthesis work also included persona creation, with a specific focus on bias-aware construction techniques: using sketches instead of photographs to avoid triggering gender and racial assumptions, omitting demographic fields (like sex) when they were not relevant to the design context, and structuring “Needs and Goals” to capture pain points and desired outcomes. I used the same principles when representing participants in this study.

What I Found

Access is not the only problem

Geographic access to food (proximity to grocery stores, transportation) was a real barrier for some participants. But it was rarely the only barrier and often not the primary one. The more consistent theme was the cognitive and emotional load of managing food insecurity over time: the constant calculation, the planning around unreliable income cycles, the social navigation of using programs that carry stigma.

Existing systems create their own friction

SNAP, food pantries, and community support programs appeared consistently in participant accounts. Participants described scheduling complexity, eligibility bureaucracy, inconsistent availability of preferred or culturally relevant foods, and the visibility cost of using programs in small communities where anonymity is hard to maintain.

Workarounds cost attention

Several participants had developed elaborate, effective workarounds: strategies that demonstrated real ingenuity about how to stretch food budgets, coordinate with neighbors, or time purchases around sales cycles. Those workarounds take constant attention.

Poverty is the root, but policy creates compounding failures

Interview participants and the questionnaire data both pointed to poverty as the primary driver of food insecurity. Policy and institutional structure compounded it. One participant reported a gap in food-assistance coverage after taking custody of a child outside the immediate family. I did not independently verify the eligibility rule, so this is the participant's account of the system and may not reflect the actual policy. The reported outcome was inadequate food assistance during a period of acute vulnerability.

Resource awareness is lower than expected, even among professionals

The questionnaire included “don't know what resources are available” as a rankable barrier, and participants rated it more highly than anticipated. This matched the interviews: even the family services administrator had limited awareness of food resources in the region. If people working in adjacent professional roles do not know what is available, residents managing food insecurity on their own are unlikely to know more.

Jobs-to-Be-Done (JTBD)

Alongside the primary research, I wrote a critical analysis of a published Jobs-to-Be-Done (JTBD) study. The paper (Domenici et al., 2025) applied JTBD to consumer meat product innovation in a three-phase study with interviews, semiotic analysis, and concept validation.

The central problem with the Domenici study was that it called its findings “jobs” when they were requirements. Statements like “it should be easy and quick to prepare” or “it should elicit positive emotions” do not follow the JTBD format: “When I am in [context], I want to [job] so I can [outcome] because [motivation].” The researchers also skipped observation, going straight to interviews, and never classified their findings into functional, emotional, or social job layers. The study uncovered consumer preferences and called them innovations: the concepts it validated (meal boxes, recipe recommendations) already existed in the market.

JTBD says people “hire” products and services to accomplish functional goals, which suits consumer products such as the milkshake bought for a morning commute. Applied to my food insecurity data, the functional layer was still useful: participants wanted reliable access, reduced planning burden, and options that did not require them to sacrifice quality or dignity.

For people managing chronic constraint, the functional job is often straightforward. The emotional job (maintain dignity, avoid judgment, preserve a sense of agency) is the harder design problem, so a JTBD analysis here has to put the emotional and social layers first.

What a Longer Engagement Would Add

A longer discovery engagement would add:

  • Participatory design from the outset. Community members with lived experience of food insecurity should help shape the research questions as well as answer them.
  • Stakeholder mapping across the food system. Interviewing food bank staff, SNAP case workers, community organizers, and local farmers alongside residents would show the systemic constraints that participants experience downstream.
  • Longitudinal observation.A single interview captures a moment. Understanding how people's situations and strategies shift across a month, a season, or a benefit cycle requires return visits or diary studies.
  • Design recommendations with an implementation path. A professional deliverable would include prioritized opportunity areas, initial concepts, and a clear line from research finding to design direction.
  • Community validation. Before any recommendations go forward, the community the data came from should review the synthesis and say whether the interpretation is right.

Skills Demonstrated

Screener design for sensitive populationsSemi-structured interview protocol designQualitative interview facilitationAffinity diagramming at scaleInsight synthesis from transcriptsQuestionnaire design (post-qualitative)Survey item construction and rationaleMixed methods research sequencingJTBD analysis and methodological critiquePersona development (bias-aware)Research ethics awarenessDiscovery-to-recommendation framing
FROM THE AFFINITY DIAGRAM · MAHONING VALLEY

Finding food and finding help came up together

In the affinity diagram, conversations about food access sit beside references to food banks, vouchers, WIC, grocery options, and how people hear about programs.

Affinity diagram · page 1Food access and finding programs

The cluster is paraphrased here. Participant quotes are not reproduced.

Decision carried forwardAsk how support is found and used

The cluster led to a research question about how people find support and whether it fits them.

Source Food insecurity affinity diagram, page 1.

Original Coursework (PDF)